Evaluate

How we examine an actor

We read what the actor published, record what it says in its own words, and score it against the rubric. The record is a ledger anyone can read.

The rubric

Six steps, 0 to 5

Each score tier states the evidence it requires. A higher score never means a better story, only better evidence.

012345
The evidence ledger

Eight fields per entry

Every finding is one row, with the same fields each time.

ActorSpherePillarSourceDirect quoteAudit questionScore, 0 to 5Verification
Sphere

Tech enterprises

System cards, responsible scaling policies, frontier model commitments and open-weights release summaries.

Sphere

Regulators and sovereign bodies

EU AI Act codes of practice, the UK AI Security Institute framework and China's generative AI measures.

Sphere

Academia and watchdogs

Benchmark results, independent shadow audits, red-team papers and vulnerability disclosures.

Sphere

Moral, philosophical and religious bodies

The Rome Call for AI Ethics and the UNESCO Recommendation on the Ethics of AI.

First audit

Frontier AI security and provider accountability

The ten most common security failure modes across 2,311 research papers, mapped to seven providers.

Read the audit